f0ebe4973f
commit to kern_synch.c:
----------------------------
revision 1.55
date: 1999/02/23 02:56:03; author: ross; state: Exp; lines: +39 -10
Scheduler bug fixes and reorganization
* fix the ancient nice(1) bug, where nice +20 processes incorrectly
steal 10 - 20% of the CPU, (or even more depending on load average)
* provide a new schedclk() mechanism at a new clock at schedhz, so high
platform hz values don't cause nice +0 processes to look like they are
niced
* change the algorithm slightly, and reorganize the code a lot
* fix percent-CPU calculation bugs, and eliminate some no-op code
=== nice bug === Correctly divide the scheduler queues between niced and
compute-bound processes. The current nice weight of two (sort of, see
`algorithm change' below) neatly divides the USRPRI queues in half; this
should have been used to clip p_estcpu, instead of UCHAR_MAX. Besides
being the wrong amount, clipping an unsigned char to UCHAR_MAX is a no-op,
and it was done after decay_cpu() which can only _reduce_ the value. It
has to be kept <= NICE_WEIGHT * PRIO_MAX - PPQ or processes can
scheduler-penalize themselves onto the same queue as nice +20 processes.
(Or even a higher one.)
=== New schedclk() mechansism === Some platforms should be cutting down
stathz before hitting the scheduler, since the scheduler algorithm only
works right in the vicinity of 64 Hz. Rather than prescale hz, then scale
back and forth by 4 every time p_estcpu is touched (each occurance an
abstraction violation), use p_estcpu without scaling and require schedhz
to be generated directly at the right frequency. Use a default stathz (well,
actually, profhz) / 4, so nothing changes unless a platform defines schedhz
and a new clock. Define these for alpha, where hz==1024, and nice was
totally broke.
=== Algorithm change === The nice value used to be added to the
exponentially-decayed scheduler history value p_estcpu, in _addition_ to
be incorporated directly (with greater wieght) into the priority calculation.
At first glance, it appears to be a pointless increase of 1/8 the nice
effect (pri = p_estcpu/4 + nice*2), but it's actually at least 3x that
because it will ramp up linearly but be decayed only exponentially, thus
converging to an additional .75 nice for a loadaverage of one. I killed
this, it makes the behavior hard to control, almost impossible to analyze,
and the effect (~~nothing at for the first second, then somewhat increased
niceness after three seconds or more, depending on load average) pointless.
=== Other bugs === hz -> profhz in the p_pctcpu = f(p_cpticks) calcuation.
Collect scheduler functionality. Try to put each abstraction in just one
place.
----------------------------
The details are a little different in FreeBSD:
=== nice bug === Fixing this is the main point of this commit. We use
essentially the same clipping rule as NetBSD (our limit on p_estcpu
differs by a scale factor). However, clipping at all is fundamentally
bad. It gives free CPU the hoggiest hogs once they reach the limit, and
reaching the limit is normal for long-running hogs. This will be fixed
later.
=== New schedclk() mechanism === We don't use the NetBSD schedclk()
(now schedclock()) mechanism. We require (real)stathz to be about 128
and scale by an extra factor of 2 compared with NetBSD's statclock().
We scale p_estcpu instead of scaling the clock. This is more accurate
and flexible.
=== Algorithm change === Same change.
=== Other bugs === The p_pctcpu bug was fixed long ago. We don't try as
hard to abstract functionality yet.
Related changes: the new limit on p_estcpu must be exported to kern_exit.c
for clipping in wait1().
Agreed with by: dufault
|
||
|---|---|---|
| bin | ||
| contrib | ||
| crypto | ||
| etc | ||
| games | ||
| gnu | ||
| include | ||
| kerberos5 | ||
| kerberosIV | ||
| lib | ||
| libexec | ||
| release | ||
| sbin | ||
| secure | ||
| share | ||
| sys | ||
| tools | ||
| usr.bin | ||
| usr.sbin | ||
| COPYRIGHT | ||
| Makefile | ||
| Makefile.inc0 | ||
| Makefile.inc1 | ||
| Makefile.upgrade | ||
| README | ||
| UPDATING | ||
README
This is the top level of the FreeBSD source directory. This file was last revised on: $FreeBSD$ For copyright information, please see the file COPYRIGHT in this directory (additional copyright information also exists for some sources in this tree - please see the specific source directories for more information). The Makefile in this directory supports a number of targets for building components (or all) of the FreeBSD source tree, the most commonly used one being ``world'', which rebuilds and installs everything in the FreeBSD system from the source tree except the kernel and the contents of /etc. Please see the top of the Makefile in this directory for more information on the standard build targets and compile-time flags. Building a kernel with config(8) is a somewhat more involved process, documentation for which can be found at: http://www.freebsd.org/handbook/kernelconfig.html And in the config(8) man page. The sample kernel configuration files reside in the sys/i386/conf sub-directory (assuming that you've installed the kernel sources), the file named GENERIC being the one used to build your initial installation kernel. The file LINT contains entries for all possible devices, not just those commonly used, and is meant more as a general reference than an actual kernel configuration file (a kernel built from it wouldn't even run). Source Roadmap: --------------- bin System/User commands. contrib Packages contributed by 3rd parties. crypto Export controlled stuff (see crypto/README). etc Template files for /etc games Amusements. gnu Various commands and libraries under the GNU Public License. Please see gnu/COPYING* for more information. include System include files. kerberosIV Kerberos package. lib System libraries. libexec System daemons. release Release building Makefile & associated tools. sbin System commands. secure DES and DES-related utilities - NOT FOR EXPORT! share Shared resources. sys Kernel sources. tools Utilities for regression testing and miscellaneous tasks. usr.bin User commands. usr.sbin System administration commands. For information on synchronizing your source tree with one or more of the FreeBSD Project's development branches, please see: http://www.freebsd.org/handbook/synching.html