Merge branch 'optval_affiliated_keywords'

notes/affiliated_keyword_investigation/analysis.org

@@ -0,0 +1,42 @@
+* Elisp Structure
+| Keyword | Single        | Double        | Single Optval | Double Optval |
+|---------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------|
+| CAPTION | objtree       | objtree       | objtree       | objtree       |
+| DATA    | quoted(:name) | quoted(:name) | -             | -             |
+| HEADER  | list(quoted)  | list(quoted)  | -             | -             |
+| NAME    | quoted(:name) | quoted(:name) | -             | -             |
+| PLOT    | quoted(:plot) | quoted(:plot) | -             | -             |
+| RESULTS | optional pair | optional pair | optional pair | optional pair |
+* types
+** objtree
+Outer list: 1 per keyword
+next list: first entry = list of objects for value. remaining entries = optval
+** list(quoted)
+List of quoted strings, 1 per keyword
+** quoted(NAME)
+Quoted string under the NAME property (for example quoted(:name))
+** optional pair
+When optval is supplied this is an alist with the field value being the real value and the 3nd value being the optval.
+#+begin_src elisp
+  ("*f*" . "*bar*")
+#+end_src
+
+When optval is not supplied this is a list containing a single string of the last occurrence of this keyword.
+#+begin_src elisp
+  ("*c*")
+#+end_src
+* Default settings
+#+begin_src text
+  org-element-dual-keywords ("CAPTION" "RESULTS")
+  org-element-parsed-keywords ("CAPTION")
+  org-element-multiple-keywords ("CAPTION" "HEADER")
+  org-babel-results-keyword "RESULTS"
+#+end_src
+* Analysis
+We don't have an example of a parsed non-dual keyword
+
+Looks like multiple triggers list 1 per keyword
+
+dual triggers support for optval
+
+parsed triggers objects

notes/affiliated_keyword_investigation/run_test.bash

@@ -0,0 +1,31 @@
+#!/usr/bin/env bash
+#
+set -euo pipefail
+IFS=$'\n\t'
+DIR="$( cd "$( dirname "${BASH_SOURCE[0]}" )" && pwd )"
+
+file_path="${DIR}/test_document.org"
+
+for TARGET_VARIABLE in RESULTS CAPTION HEADER DATA NAME PLOT; do
+    INIT_SCRIPT=$(cat <<EOF
+(progn
+     (erase-buffer)
+     (require 'org)
+     (defun org-table-align () t)
+     (setq vc-handled-backends nil)
+     (find-file "/input/${file_path}")
+     (org-mode)
+     (replace-regexp-in-region "foo" "${TARGET_VARIABLE}")
+     (message "%s" (pp-to-string (org-element-parse-buffer)))
+)
+EOF
+               )
+    docker run --init --rm -i --mount type=tmpfs,destination=/tmp -v "/:/input:ro" -w /input --entrypoint "" organic-test emacs -q --no-site-file --no-splash --batch --eval "$INIT_SCRIPT" 2> "${DIR}/${TARGET_VARIABLE}"
+done
+
+# exec docker run --init --rm -i -t --mount type=tmpfs,destination=/tmp -v "/:/input:ro" -w /input --entrypoint "" organic-test emacs -q --no-site-file --no-splash --eval "$INIT_SCRIPT"
+
+# org-element-dual-keywords ("CAPTION" "RESULTS")
+# org-element-parsed-keywords ("CAPTION")
+# org-element-multiple-keywords ("CAPTION" "HEADER")
+# org-babel-results-keyword "RESULTS"

notes/affiliated_keyword_investigation/test_document.org

@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
+# Single instance
+#+foo: *a*
+#+begin_example
+
+#+end_example
+
+# Two instances
+#+foo: *b*
+#+foo: *c*
+#+begin_example
+
+#+end_example
+
+# Single with optval
+#+foo[*bar*]: *d*
+#+begin_example
+
+#+end_example
+
+# Two with optval
+#+foo[*bar*]: *e*
+#+foo[*bar*]: *f*
+#+begin_example
+
+#+end_example

src/compare/compare_field.rs

@@ -16,7 +16,6 @@ use super::util::get_property_unquoted_atom;
 use crate::types::AstNode;
 use crate::types::CharOffsetInLine;
 use crate::types::LineNumber;
-use crate::types::Object;
 use crate::types::RetainLabels;
 use crate::types::SwitchNumberLines;
 
@@ -288,6 +287,107 @@ pub(crate) fn compare_property_set_of_quoted_string<
     Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::NoChange)
 }
 
+pub(crate) fn compare_property_optional_pair<
+    'b,
+    's,
+    'x,
+    R,
+    RV: AsRef<str> + std::fmt::Debug,
+    ROV: AsRef<str> + std::fmt::Debug,
+    RG: Fn(R) -> Option<(Option<ROV>, RV)>,
+>(
+    _source: &'s str,
+    emacs: &'b Token<'s>,
+    rust_node: R,
+    emacs_field: &'x str,
+    rust_value_getter: RG,
+) -> Result<ComparePropertiesResult<'b, 's>, Box<dyn std::error::Error>> {
+    let value = get_property(emacs, emacs_field)?
+        .map(Token::as_list)
+        .map_or(Ok(None), |r| r.map(Some))?;
+    let rust_value = rust_value_getter(rust_node);
+    match (value, &rust_value) {
+        (None, None) => {}
+        (None, Some(_)) | (Some(_), None) => {
+            let this_status = DiffStatus::Bad;
+            let message = Some(format!(
+                "{} mismatch (emacs != rust) {:?} != {:?}",
+                emacs_field, value, rust_value
+            ));
+            return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::SelfChange(this_status, message));
+        }
+        (Some(el), Some((Some(_), _))) if el.len() != 3 => {
+            let this_status = DiffStatus::Bad;
+            let message = Some(format!(
+                "{} mismatch (emacs != rust) {:?} != {:?}",
+                emacs_field, value, rust_value
+            ));
+            return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::SelfChange(this_status, message));
+        }
+        (Some(el), Some((None, _))) if el.len() != 1 => {
+            let this_status = DiffStatus::Bad;
+            let message = Some(format!(
+                "{} mismatch (emacs != rust) {:?} != {:?}",
+                emacs_field, value, rust_value
+            ));
+            return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::SelfChange(this_status, message));
+        }
+        (Some(el), Some((Some(orl), rl))) => {
+            let e = el
+                .first()
+                .map(Token::as_atom)
+                .map_or(Ok(None), |r| r.map(Some))?
+                .map(unquote)
+                .map_or(Ok(None), |r| r.map(Some))?
+                .expect("Above match proved length to be 3.");
+            let oe = el
+                .get(2)
+                .map(Token::as_atom)
+                .map_or(Ok(None), |r| r.map(Some))?
+                .map(unquote)
+                .map_or(Ok(None), |r| r.map(Some))?
+                .expect("Above match proved length to be 3.");
+            let r = rl.as_ref();
+            let or = orl.as_ref();
+            if e != r {
+                let this_status = DiffStatus::Bad;
+                let message = Some(format!(
+                    "{} mismatch (emacs != rust) {:?} != {:?}. Full list: {:?} != {:?}",
+                    emacs_field, e, r, value, rust_value
+                ));
+                return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::SelfChange(this_status, message));
+            }
+            if oe != or {
+                let this_status = DiffStatus::Bad;
+                let message = Some(format!(
+                    "{} mismatch (emacs != rust) {:?} != {:?}. Full list: {:?} != {:?}",
+                    emacs_field, e, r, value, rust_value
+                ));
+                return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::SelfChange(this_status, message));
+            }
+        }
+        (Some(el), Some((None, rl))) => {
+            let e = el
+                .first()
+                .map(Token::as_atom)
+                .map_or(Ok(None), |r| r.map(Some))?
+                .map(unquote)
+                .map_or(Ok(None), |r| r.map(Some))?
+                .expect("Above match proved length to be 1.");
+            let r = rl.as_ref();
+            if e != r {
+                let this_status = DiffStatus::Bad;
+                let message = Some(format!(
+                    "{} mismatch (emacs != rust) {:?} != {:?}. Full list: {:?} != {:?}",
+                    emacs_field, e, r, value, rust_value
+                ));
+                return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::SelfChange(this_status, message));
+            }
+        }
+    }
+    Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::NoChange)
+}
+
 pub(crate) fn compare_property_boolean<'b, 's, 'x, R, RG: Fn(R) -> bool>(
     _source: &'s str,
     emacs: &'b Token<'s>,
@@ -412,118 +512,133 @@ where
     Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::NoChange)
 }
 
-/// Special compare used for affiliate keywords that are parsed as objects.
+pub(crate) fn compare_property_object_tree<
-///
-/// Org-mode seems to store these as a 3-deep list:
-///   - Outer list with 1 element per #+caption keyword (or other parsed keyword).
-///   - Middle list which has:
-///     - first element is a list of objects representing the value after the colon.
-///     - every additional element is a list of objects from inside the square brackets (the optional value).
-pub(crate) fn compare_property_list_of_list_of_list_of_ast_nodes<
     'b,
     's,
     'x,
     R,
-    RG: Fn(R) -> Option<&'b Vec<(Option<Vec<Object<'s>>>, Vec<Object<'s>>)>>,
+    RV: std::fmt::Debug + 'b,
+    ROV: std::fmt::Debug + 'b,
+    RI: Iterator<Item = &'b (Option<Vec<ROV>>, Vec<RV>)> + ExactSizeIterator + std::fmt::Debug,
+    RG: Fn(R) -> Option<RI>,
 >(
     source: &'s str,
     emacs: &'b Token<'s>,
     rust_node: R,
     emacs_field: &'x str,
     rust_value_getter: RG,
-) -> Result<ComparePropertiesResult<'b, 's>, Box<dyn std::error::Error>> {
+) -> Result<ComparePropertiesResult<'b, 's>, Box<dyn std::error::Error>>
-    // TODO: Replace Object<'s> with generics. I hard-coded Object in to make lifetimes easier.
+where
-    let rust_value = rust_value_getter(rust_node);
+    AstNode<'b, 's>: From<&'b RV>,
+    AstNode<'b, 's>: From<&'b ROV>,
+{
     let value = get_property(emacs, emacs_field)?
         .map(Token::as_list)
         .map_or(Ok(None), |r| r.map(Some))?;
-    let (value, rust_value) = match (value, rust_value) {
+    let rust_value = rust_value_getter(rust_node);
+    let (outer_emacs_list, outer_rust_list) = match (value, rust_value) {
         (None, None) => {
             return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::NoChange);
         }
-        (None, Some(_)) | (Some(_), None) => {
+        (None, rv @ Some(_)) | (Some(_), rv @ None) => {
             let this_status = DiffStatus::Bad;
             let message = Some(format!(
                 "{} mismatch (emacs != rust) {:?} != {:?}",
-                emacs_field, value, rust_value
+                emacs_field, value, rv
             ));
             return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::SelfChange(this_status, message));
         }
-        (Some(value), Some(rust_value)) if value.len() != rust_value.len() => {
+        (Some(el), Some(rl)) if el.len() != rl.len() => {
             let this_status = DiffStatus::Bad;
             let message = Some(format!(
                 "{} mismatch (emacs != rust) {:?} != {:?}",
-                emacs_field, value, rust_value
+                emacs_field, el, rl
             ));
             return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::SelfChange(this_status, message));
         }
-        (Some(value), Some(rust_value)) => (value, rust_value),
+        (Some(el), Some(rl)) => (el, rl),
     };
+    let mut full_status: Vec<DiffEntry<'b, 's>> = Vec::with_capacity(outer_rust_list.len());
 
-    let mut full_status: Vec<DiffEntry<'b, 's>> = Vec::with_capacity(rust_value.len());
+    for (kw_e, kw_r) in outer_emacs_list.into_iter().zip(outer_rust_list) {
-
+        let kw_e = kw_e.as_list()?;
-    // Iterate the outer lists
+        let child_status_length = kw_r.1.len() + kw_r.0.as_ref().map(|opt| opt.len()).unwrap_or(0);
-    for (value, (rust_optional, rust_value)) in value.iter().zip(rust_value.iter()) {
+        let mut child_status: Vec<DiffEntry<'b, 's>> = Vec::with_capacity(child_status_length);
-        let mut middle_value = value.as_list()?.iter();
+        if let Some(or) = &kw_r.0 {
-        // First element of middle list is the mandatory value (the value past the colon).
+            // if optional value
-        let mandatory_value = middle_value.next();
+            let mut kw_e = kw_e.into_iter();
-        let mandatory_value = match mandatory_value {
+            // First element is a list representing the mandatory value.
-            Some(mandatory_value) => mandatory_value,
+            if let Some(val_e) = kw_e.next() {
-            None => {
+                let el = val_e.as_list()?;
+                if el.len() != kw_r.1.len() {
+                    let this_status = DiffStatus::Bad;
+                    let message = Some(format!(
+                        "{} mismatch (emacs != rust) {:?} != {:?}",
+                        emacs_field, kw_e, kw_r
+                    ));
+                    return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::SelfChange(this_status, message));
+                }
+                for (e, r) in el.into_iter().zip(kw_r.1.iter()) {
+                    child_status.push(compare_ast_node(source, e, r.into())?);
+                }
+            } else {
                 let this_status = DiffStatus::Bad;
                 let message = Some(format!(
                     "{} mismatch (emacs != rust) {:?} != {:?}",
-                    emacs_field, value, rust_value
+                    emacs_field, kw_e, kw_r
                 ));
                 return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::SelfChange(this_status, message));
             }
-        };
+            // Remaining elements are the optional value.
-
+            if kw_e.len() != or.len() {
-        // Compare optional value
-        if let Some(rust_optional) = rust_optional {
-            let mut child_status: Vec<DiffEntry<'b, 's>> = Vec::with_capacity(rust_value.len());
-            if rust_optional.len() != middle_value.len() {
                 let this_status = DiffStatus::Bad;
                 let message = Some(format!(
-                    "{} optional value length mismatch (emacs != rust) {} != {} | {:?}",
+                    "{} mismatch (emacs != rust) {:?} != {:?}",
-                    emacs_field,
+                    emacs_field, kw_e, kw_r
-                    middle_value.len(),
-                    rust_optional.len(),
-                    rust_optional
                 ));
                 return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::SelfChange(this_status, message));
             }
-            for (e, r) in middle_value.zip(rust_optional) {
+            for (e, r) in kw_e.zip(or.iter()) {
                 child_status.push(compare_ast_node(source, e, r.into())?);
             }
-            if !child_status.is_empty() {
+        } else {
-                let diff_scope = artificial_diff_scope("optional value", child_status)?;
+            // if no optional value
-                full_status.push(diff_scope);
+            if !kw_e.len() == 1 {
+                let this_status = DiffStatus::Bad;
+                let message = Some(format!(
+                    "{} mismatch (emacs != rust) {:?} != {:?}",
+                    emacs_field, kw_e, kw_r
+                ));
+                return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::SelfChange(this_status, message));
             }
-        }
 
-        // Compare mandatory value
+            let e = kw_e
-        let mut child_status: Vec<DiffEntry<'b, 's>> = Vec::with_capacity(rust_value.len());
+                .first()
-        let mandatory_value = mandatory_value.as_list()?;
+                .map(Token::as_list)
-        if rust_value.len() != mandatory_value.len() {
+                .map_or(Ok(None), |r| r.map(Some))?
-            let this_status = DiffStatus::Bad;
+                .expect("The above if-statement proves this will be Some.")
-            let message = Some(format!(
+                .iter();
-                "{} mandatory value length mismatch (emacs != rust) {} != {} | {:?}",
+            let r = kw_r.1.iter();
-                emacs_field,
+
-                mandatory_value.len(),
+            if e.len() != r.len() {
-                rust_value.len(),
+                let this_status = DiffStatus::Bad;
-                rust_value
+                let message = Some(format!(
-            ));
+                    "{} mismatch (emacs != rust) {:?} != {:?}",
-            return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::SelfChange(this_status, message));
+                    emacs_field, kw_e, kw_r
-        }
+                ));
-        for (e, r) in mandatory_value.iter().zip(rust_value) {
+                return Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::SelfChange(this_status, message));
-            child_status.push(compare_ast_node(source, e, r.into())?);
+            }
+
+            for (e, r) in e.zip(r) {
+                child_status.push(compare_ast_node(source, e, r.into())?);
+            }
         }
         if !child_status.is_empty() {
             let diff_scope = artificial_diff_scope("mandatory value", child_status)?;
             full_status.push(diff_scope);
         }
     }
+
     if full_status.is_empty() {
         Ok(ComparePropertiesResult::NoChange)
     } else {

src/compare/util.rs

@@ -1,7 +1,8 @@
 use std::str::FromStr;
 
-use super::compare_field::compare_property_list_of_list_of_list_of_ast_nodes;
 use super::compare_field::compare_property_list_of_quoted_string;
+use super::compare_field::compare_property_object_tree;
+use super::compare_field::compare_property_optional_pair;
 use super::compare_field::compare_property_quoted_string;
 use super::compare_field::ComparePropertiesResult;
 use super::diff::DiffEntry;
@@ -376,13 +377,23 @@ where
                 )?;
                 ret.push(diff);
             }
-            AffiliatedKeywordValue::ListOfListsOfObjects(rust_value) => {
+            AffiliatedKeywordValue::OptionalPair { optval, val } => {
-                let diff = compare_property_list_of_list_of_list_of_ast_nodes(
+                let diff = compare_property_optional_pair(
                     source,
                     emacs,
                     rust,
                     emacs_property_name.as_str(),
-                    |_| Some(rust_value),
+                    |_| Some((*optval, *val)),
+                )?;
+                ret.push(diff);
+            }
+            AffiliatedKeywordValue::ObjectTree(rust_value) => {
+                let diff = compare_property_object_tree(
+                    source,
+                    emacs,
+                    rust,
+                    emacs_property_name.as_str(),
+                    |_| Some(rust_value.iter()),
                 )?;
                 ret.push(diff);
             }

src/parser/affiliated_keyword.rs

@@ -35,75 +35,86 @@ where
     let mut ret = BTreeMap::new();
     for kw in input {
         let translated_name = translate_name(global_settings, kw.key);
-        if is_single_string_keyword(global_settings, translated_name.as_str()) {
+        let keyword_type = identify_keyword_type(global_settings, translated_name.as_str());
-            ret.insert(
+        match keyword_type {
-                translated_name,
+            AffiliatedKeywordType::SingleString => {
-                AffiliatedKeywordValue::SingleString(kw.value),
+                ret.insert(
-            );
+                    translated_name,
-        } else if is_list_of_single_string_keyword(global_settings, translated_name.as_str()) {
+                    AffiliatedKeywordValue::SingleString(kw.value),
-            let list_of_strings = ret
+                );
-                .entry(translated_name)
-                .or_insert_with(|| AffiliatedKeywordValue::ListOfStrings(Vec::with_capacity(1)));
-            match list_of_strings {
-                AffiliatedKeywordValue::ListOfStrings(list_of_strings)
-                    if list_of_strings.is_empty() =>
-                {
-                    list_of_strings.push(kw.value);
-                }
-                AffiliatedKeywordValue::ListOfStrings(list_of_strings) => {
-                    list_of_strings.clear();
-                    list_of_strings.push(kw.value);
-                }
-                _ => panic!("Invalid AffiliatedKeywordValue type."),
             }
-        } else if is_list_of_objects_keyword(global_settings, translated_name.as_str()) {
+            AffiliatedKeywordType::ListOfStrings => {
-            let initial_context = ContextElement::document_context();
+                let list_of_strings = ret.entry(translated_name).or_insert_with(|| {
-            let initial_context = Context::new(global_settings, List::new(&initial_context));
+                    AffiliatedKeywordValue::ListOfStrings(Vec::with_capacity(1))
-
+                });
-            let (_remaining, optional_objects) = opt(all_consuming(map(
+                match list_of_strings {
-                tuple((
+                    AffiliatedKeywordValue::ListOfStrings(list_of_strings) => {
-                    take_until("["),
+                        list_of_strings.push(kw.value);
-                    tag("["),
+                    }
-                    map_parser(
+                    _ => panic!("Invalid AffiliatedKeywordValue type."),
+                }
+            }
+            AffiliatedKeywordType::OptionalPair => {
+                let (_remaining, optional_string) = opt(all_consuming(map(
+                    tuple((
+                        take_until::<_, &str, nom::error::Error<_>>("["),
+                        tag("["),
                         recognize(many_till(anychar, peek(tuple((tag("]"), eof))))),
-                        confine_context(|i| {
+                        tag("]"),
-                            all_consuming(many0(parser_with_context!(standard_set_object)(
+                        eof,
-                                &initial_context,
+                    )),
-                            )))(i)
+                    |(_, _, objects, _, _)| objects,
-                        }),
+                )))(kw.key.into())
-                    ),
+                .expect("Parser should always succeed.");
-                    tag("]"),
+                ret.insert(
-                    eof,
+                    translated_name,
-                )),
+                    AffiliatedKeywordValue::OptionalPair {
-                |(_, _, objects, _, _)| objects,
+                        optval: optional_string,
-            )))(kw.key.into())
+                        val: kw.value,
-            .expect("Object parser should always succeed.");
+                    },
+                );
+            }
+            AffiliatedKeywordType::ObjectTree => {
+                let initial_context = ContextElement::document_context();
+                let initial_context = Context::new(global_settings, List::new(&initial_context));
 
-            // TODO: This should be omitting footnote references
+                let (_remaining, optional_objects) = opt(all_consuming(map(
-            let (_remaining, objects) = all_consuming(many0(parser_with_context!(
+                    tuple((
-                standard_set_object
+                        take_until("["),
-            )(&initial_context)))(kw.value.into())
+                        tag("["),
-            .expect("Object parser should always succeed.");
+                        map_parser(
-            let list_of_lists = ret.entry(translated_name).or_insert_with(|| {
+                            recognize(many_till(anychar, peek(tuple((tag("]"), eof))))),
-                AffiliatedKeywordValue::ListOfListsOfObjects(Vec::with_capacity(1))
+                            confine_context(|i| {
-            });
+                                all_consuming(many0(parser_with_context!(standard_set_object)(
-            match list_of_lists {
+                                    &initial_context,
-                AffiliatedKeywordValue::ListOfListsOfObjects(list_of_lists) => {
+                                )))(i)
-                    list_of_lists.push((optional_objects, objects));
+                            }),
+                        ),
+                        tag("]"),
+                        eof,
+                    )),
+                    |(_, _, objects, _, _)| objects,
+                )))(kw.key.into())
+                .expect("Object parser should always succeed.");
+
+                // TODO: This should be omitting footnote references
+                let (_remaining, objects) =
+                    all_consuming(many0(parser_with_context!(standard_set_object)(
+                        &initial_context,
+                    )))(kw.value.into())
+                    .expect("Object parser should always succeed.");
+
+                let entry_per_keyword_list = ret
+                    .entry(translated_name)
+                    .or_insert_with(|| AffiliatedKeywordValue::ObjectTree(Vec::with_capacity(1)));
+                match entry_per_keyword_list {
+                    AffiliatedKeywordValue::ObjectTree(entry_per_keyword_list) => {
+                        entry_per_keyword_list.push((optional_objects, objects));
+                    }
+                    _ => panic!("Invalid AffiliatedKeywordValue type."),
                 }
-                _ => panic!("Invalid AffiliatedKeywordValue type."),
             }
-        } else {
+        };
-            let list_of_strings = ret
-                .entry(translated_name)
-                .or_insert_with(|| AffiliatedKeywordValue::ListOfStrings(Vec::with_capacity(1)));
-            match list_of_strings {
-                AffiliatedKeywordValue::ListOfStrings(list_of_strings) => {
-                    list_of_strings.push(kw.value);
-                }
-                _ => panic!("Invalid AffiliatedKeywordValue type."),
-            }
-        }
     }
     AffiliatedKeywords { keywords: ret }
 }
@@ -121,40 +132,37 @@ fn translate_name<'g, 's>(global_settings: &'g GlobalSettings<'g, 's>, name: &'s
     name_until_optval.to_lowercase()
 }
 
-fn is_single_string_keyword<'g, 's>(
+enum AffiliatedKeywordType {
-    _global_settings: &'g GlobalSettings<'g, 's>,
+    SingleString,
-    name: &'s str,
+    ListOfStrings,
-) -> bool {
+    OptionalPair,
-    // TODO: Is this defined by an elisp variable?
+    ObjectTree,
-    for single_string_name in ["plot", "name"] {
-        if name.eq_ignore_ascii_case(single_string_name) {
-            return true;
-        }
-    }
-    false
 }
 
-fn is_list_of_single_string_keyword<'g, 's>(
+fn identify_keyword_type<'g, 's>(
-    _global_settings: &'g GlobalSettings<'g, 's>,
-    name: &'s str,
-) -> bool {
-    // TODO: Is this defined by an elisp variable?
-    for single_string_name in ["results"] {
-        if name.eq_ignore_ascii_case(single_string_name) {
-            return true;
-        }
-    }
-    false
-}
-
-fn is_list_of_objects_keyword<'g, 's>(
     global_settings: &'g GlobalSettings<'g, 's>,
     name: &'s str,
-) -> bool {
+) -> AffiliatedKeywordType {
-    for parsed_keyword in global_settings.element_parsed_keywords {
+    let is_multiple = ["CAPTION", "HEADER"]
-        if name.eq_ignore_ascii_case(parsed_keyword) {
+        .into_iter()
-            return true;
+        .any(|candidate| name.eq_ignore_ascii_case(candidate))
-        }
+        || name.to_lowercase().starts_with("attr_");
+    let is_parsed = global_settings
+        .element_parsed_keywords
+        .iter()
+        .any(|candidate| name.eq_ignore_ascii_case(candidate));
+    let can_have_optval = global_settings
+        .element_dual_keywords
+        .iter()
+        .any(|candidate| name.eq_ignore_ascii_case(candidate));
+    match (is_multiple, is_parsed, can_have_optval) {
+        (true, true, true) => AffiliatedKeywordType::ObjectTree,
+        (true, true, false) => unreachable!("Nothing like this exists in upstream org-mode."),
+        (true, false, true) => unreachable!("Nothing like this exists in upstream org-mode."),
+        (true, false, false) => AffiliatedKeywordType::ListOfStrings,
+        (false, true, true) => unreachable!("Nothing like this exists in upstream org-mode."),
+        (false, true, false) => unreachable!("Nothing like this exists in upstream org-mode."),
+        (false, false, true) => AffiliatedKeywordType::OptionalPair,
+        (false, false, false) => AffiliatedKeywordType::SingleString,
     }
-    false
 }

src/types/affiliated_keyword.rs

@@ -6,7 +6,11 @@ use super::Object;
 pub enum AffiliatedKeywordValue<'s> {
     SingleString(&'s str),
     ListOfStrings(Vec<&'s str>),
-    ListOfListsOfObjects(Vec<(Option<Vec<Object<'s>>>, Vec<Object<'s>>)>),
+    OptionalPair {
+        optval: Option<&'s str>,
+        val: &'s str,
+    },
+    ObjectTree(Vec<(Option<Vec<Object<'s>>>, Vec<Object<'s>>)>),
 }
 
 #[derive(Debug)]